How to set up an obeya room?
Dear Gemba Coach.
I would like to set up an obeya room – where should I start? What is the simplest way to do it?
Interesting question – I'm not sure there is a single answer to this, but I can share how I do it with the CEOs I know. Your first problem will probably be… finding a room! In fact, any wall will do, even one in the hallway.
What is the problem we are trying to solve? Think of a sports team. All the players want to go out on the field and play. Deep down, they are convinced that if the coach just let them go in and give it their best, they would win. But how likely is that to happen? The coach knows that he must first train each player individually and discuss strategy with the team, so that they do more than chase the ball and instead bring thought and cooperation to their actions in order to win. The players accept this, but (and this is human nature) they often resent the time they spend without the ball.
Management teams are, rightly, organized by specialty. This leads to silos. We cannot do away with silos, because most operations are now so specialized that the silo acts as a university. Companies that have tried “flat” and “process-focused” organizations have come to regret the decision, because without specialization, knowledge simply disappears like snow in the sun. The dream of a flat, process organization is still around, but successful examples are few (mostly in the early stage, when there is not that much specialized knowledge around). On the other hand, functional specialization, if not handled correctly, leads to massive inefficiency and to a tendency for directors to fight turf wars and internal issues rather than worry about customer problems: the focus inevitably turns inward.
What to focus on
In my view, the purpose of the obeya is to keep the management team's eyes focused and to develop teamwork. To do this, I usually concentrate on three topics:
- Customer complaints: value is always mysterious, and we constantly need to refocus the management team on its purpose: serving customers. By looking at all customer complaints, we keep collective attention focused on them. We don't expect to fix everything, but we want to focus on what makes the customer complain – what was the customer doing that created the problem? Are customers behaving differently? Facts are facts, and every customer complaint is a fact that our product or service was inadequate for one person, and we need to find out why. The obeya is there to create space to think about our customers and the value we deliver.
- Key performance indicators and improvement objectives: every sports team needs a clear way of scoring points/goals collectively in order to fight together – every sport has a scoring scheme. In lean, our key indicators are safety incidents, quality complaints, missed deliveries, inventory, productivity and implemented suggestions, plus a few specific ones, such as new products launched on time or the number of engineering changes requested after tooling, and so on. In my experience, having up to seven indicators is fine; if there are more than seven, people lose interest in some of them. Two specific lean features should be looked for:
- A dynamic objective: the difference between operational excellence and lean excellence is that, in lean, we don't want to reach a set level, but to improve on what exists: therefore, a 2% improvement per month is very different from a target for the year – draw a dynamic line across the indicator.
- Completed A3s: once a week, a member of the management team gives a presentation of a completed A3, corresponding to one of the performance improvement topics. If there are 10 members on the team, that means each has 10 weeks to complete an A3 – the idea is not to present open problems to discuss together – that is regular work –, but to discuss the “act” implications of problems solved as a team, as well as to build confidence in our ability to solve problems and work together.
- Upcoming changes that will affect all of us: a new product or new process that is under way and that all team directors need to integrate into their current work. By posting planned changes in the obeya rooms, we can start thinking about obstacles and specific issues in order to prepare teams for the change. This will appear as a description with the name of the project leader, the plan, and a space to discuss issues.
All obeyas are different, but I can look at these three topics before entering the room and, at the very least, feel confident that a thinking space has been set up for the management team to work together on (1) customer satisfaction, (2) performance improvement kaizen and (3) preparation for the next step of change.