James Womack gives us some tips on how to sustain 5S

WOMACK'S YOKOTEN - 5S means different things to different people. What is common, however, is the difficulty of sustaining it. The author offers some tips.
I recently visited a company with the most comprehensive 5S program I have ever seen. Everything was in its well-marked place, even the staplers on office desks surrounded by blue tape to indicate the right location. And the company's lean audits begin with 5S. This is great. But what is the purpose? What is being accomplished with this considerable effort? And can it be sustained?
To think about this, let's go back to the origins of 5S, the practices named after five Japanese terms beginning with the "s" sound, translated into English as sort, set in order, shine, standardize and sustain. These practices were applied as a system in manufacturing companies in Japan in the 1950s, at a time when companies were struggling to produce with perfect quality in long processes with standardized work and precise, repetitive cycle times within takt time. The goal of 5S was to ensure that nothing prevented the work from being done within takt time and that everything needed to do the work was in the right place without the need for a "treasure hunt" - even for a second or two - by any employee in the process. As always, the developers of a lean tool - in this case, 5S - started with the work to be done and worked backward to develop practices to make it easier, better, safer and cheaper.
However, what many people heard often changed as 5S spread from its point of origin in manufacturing in Japan. I often hear 5S being advocated as a kind of "clean-up and fix-up" campaign, an "easy way to get started with lean," to boost morale, impress investors, impress customers and, in general, create a "world-class" appearance (whatever a "world-class" company may be). This is not a problem, as long as 5S also achieves its main goal: making the work possible and sustainable.
If there is confusion about the purpose of 5S in repetitive operations, it loses its meaning as we leave the factory and enter knowledge work in offices (and, increasingly, in work without offices). Do we really need to put blue tape around our staplers? Do we need to clear everything off our desks every day? Do we need to sort the supply room every week? Or does it simply make us feel better to clean our rooms as our mothers always told us to?
The way to answer these questions is to start with the work to be done. What is the work to be done? What are the steps in the process? What is the best currently known way to perform each step without interruptions and without wasting time on treasure hunts? What materials and equipment are needed for each step, and what is their standard position? How can 5S help, in what way can it help, and how rigorously do we need to audit it? I find that it is much harder to define the work outside the factory than to create 5S in office environments. But 5S in the office - no matter how aesthetically pleasing - is not worth much without rigorous work design. So, again, we need to start with the work and work backward.
Let's suppose an organization is implementing 5S for the right reasons in the right ways to improve the work. This should be easy, since the work is correctly specified. Just sort, set in order, shine, standardize and sustain the process! But the sustain part is actually very hard. In my experience as an industrial and organizational archaeologist, I have often observed the remains of 5S implementations (for example, the tattered blue tape around the empty space where tools or supplies should be and probably once were). These efforts seem to have a short half-life. In fact, "half-life" is the wrong term, because that term assumes that decay happens after a clean-up event, but with a long trajectory before all of the 5S disappears into chaos. In practice, I observe that 5S has a different curve, with the benefits disappearing completely in two short half-lives, one steep and the other in free fall. So how can we sustain 5S with the right purpose?
Here are the problems and the possible countermeasures:
5S requires a focused investment of our time (when we are in a hurry after completing a work task or tired after a long day) to provide a diffuse reward at some later time, perhaps much later. Thus, 5S must be built directly into standardized work to the point where not performing the 5S cycle at the right moment feels as strange as not installing a part on a product on an assembly line or skipping a coding step in software development.
Implementing 5S, like implementing any lean tool, requires cleaning up the management system as well. It is the management system supporting 5S, with frequent audits and rapid correction of any deficiencies discovered, that determines the fate of 5S over time. Therefore, the workplace and management clean-up must be addressed together (the consequence is that sustainable 5S can never be an "easy way to get started," but it can be a critical part of a long journey to achieve an important goal).
Lean tools work best together, but 5S is often applied in isolation.Its complementary methods of Daily Management and visual management need to be applied together to obtain and sustain the benefits of all three.
5S and the complementary practices of visual management and Daily Management need to be designed into all value-creating processes during the design of the production system rather than being retrofitted later. What I almost always see is 5S programs being retrofitted into processes that are almost invisible because of the amount of junk that has accumulated. This rework can be avoided by broadening the task of the team that designs each production system (which, of course, would like to avoid the focused effort now and let someone else worry later about the consequences when problems arise).
If we can apply all these countermeasures to all these problems, 5S for the right purpose can have a lifetime that lasts indefinitely. I hope that we, as a lean community, will progressively tackle this challenge.
Let me add a final note on personal 5S: I am not getting any younger, I have a lot on my mind and I forget things. So my personal 5S after each interaction - when I get up from my chair, leave a room, a building or even the plane when I land in a new country - is a critical part of my life. If you ever see me wandering around your gemba while periodically checking the standard locations where I keep my reading glasses, keys, iPhone, wallet, passport, notebook, PC, chargers, jacket and briefcase, please understand that this is not a neurological problem or an empty lean ritual. I am just trying to make sure that everything is in the right place so I can perform the next cycle of my work without the rework of a treasure hunt or replacing lost items. I think you may need some personal 5S too. So, on future gemba walks, perhaps we can do our personal 5S in unison.