General GENERAL

Toyota: villain

Lately I have found myself in difficult situations, often surrounded by lean change agents eager to show me their scars inflicted by re-energized resisters. People who criticize the lean philosophy have latched onto the Toyota crisis to resist change, admonishing: “You tell us to ‘be like Toyota’. Look at them now!”

Do not lose heart.

Let us recall why we sought to learn from Toyota in the first place. We did not study and seek to adapt the Toyota model because the company was perfect. Toyota was never a waste-free zone. In fact, I never thought the leaders who built Toyota were touched by a genius superior to that of other famous, influential leaders. We look to Toyota because, for reasons of grand historical coincidence, Toyota came to embody many of the ideals we wish for in human organizations. Whether one's source of inspiration is Henry Ford, W. Edwards Deming, Alfred Sloan, the Training Within Industry (TWI) program , Six Sigma, Frederick Taylor, Frank & Lilian Gilbreth, Elton Mayo, Mary Parker Follett, Henri Fayol, Max Weber, Peter Drucker, Shigeo Shingo, John Dewey, Douglas McGregor, Eli Goldratt, Michael Hammer, Peter Senge, Jim Collins, Tom Peters, Russell Ackoff, Edgar Schein, or Henry Mintzberg (Whew! Did I remember everyone?), the ideas and ideals represented by these individuals and their initiatives found their best realization at Toyota. At least for a period of time. Will that period of time last forever? Has it already ended? Since it is still too early to answer these questions, it is more important to recognize the extent to which Toyota has served as the largest-scale organizational business laboratory we have ever seen.

Culture of Control?

Even so, we must recognize that, even at its peak as an organizational GPS, Toyota was never as good as its reputation in some respects, but better in others. Both at the same time. There are still criticisms regarding the way the company worked and works that have not been fully explained, and I think it may still provide answers to our most nagging problems of human organization.

One characteristic point concerns the tension between respecting the individual while, at the same time, being extremely demanding of them. Critics say Toyota employees must sacrifice individuality for the good of the group, following rigid rules that dictate almost every facet of their lives at work. A recent article delves into this issue (‘Toyota Men's conformist ways are criticized’ (John M. Gliona, March 22, 2010) http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-toyota-man23-2010mar23,0,7100881.story?page=1) and included the statement that “The real Toyota way is a culture of control,” says Masaki Saruta, a business professor at Chukyo University in Japan. The article goes on to say “... guidelines dictate almost every facet of the workday – how they turn corners while walking on company property, where they eat their lunches and even how they get home. At this Toyota plant, employees cannot put their hands in their pockets. Inspectors report violators. People who drive to work must report their routes to their superiors. Those who travel on days off must file such details as when they are on vacation...”

People who read this article ask me: “Is that horrible description really true?”

There are, in fact, aspects of that article that are, or were, true. That was also part of the Toyota way. Toyota was never perfect, or rather we should just say, “it is always in the relentless pursuit of perfection,” as the saying goes. Some of the things described in that damning article are (or were, in some way) true, but, for the most part, they also represented the dimension of Toyota during its formative period, a dimension that some of the company's leaders wanted to change. It turns out that these things, the news bulletins, are not so easy to change. Many Toyota leaders have - sometimes consciously, sometimes unconsciously - long wanted to rid the company of precisely those less attractive dimensions described in the article.

No hands in pockets

None of this is new news. Toyota has always had its share of critics in Japan. A journalist sympathetic to communism joined Toyota as a line worker in the early 1970s and wrote about his experience in a sarcastic attack published in a book titled, in English, “Japan in the Passing Lane”. The original Japanese title was something like “Hell Factory Toyota”. The book clearly took only one side, and it was dissected in depth by a critical introduction written for the English edition by R. P. Dore.
In response to the question “Is there really an ‘inspector’ to enforce the ‘no hands in pockets’ rules?” Well, I do not know about the ‘inspectors’. But “hands in pockets” was absolutely a no-no at Toyota in the old days. Angry inspectors were not needed, but a friendly superior would gladly do it. There was a logic to explain it.

  1. Safety. You do not want people falling face-first on the floor with their hands in their pockets.
  2. Respect. There are many sides to this one.
  3. Japanese custom.
  4. Free hands display a posture of “I am ready to help,” especially in the plant.
  5. And it displays a decidedly disrespectful posture toward those who work on the line, who have no opportunity for free time to put their hands in their pockets.

This is one of the many cultural artifacts that cause confusion on the other side of the Pacific. I remember witnessing on more than one occasion Japanese managers slapping the hands of American employees when they started to slide their hands into their pockets. Not only in the plants, either. I still remember the shocked expression of a 30-year-old manager as my own boss slapped his hands with a loud smack.

Two words

If Toyota - the old Toyota, in some ways - were a person, he would be a fine, strapping boy. A disciplined conservative. The football coach who stays on his player's back like Vince Lombardi of the old Green Bay Packers. If he does not throw things like basketball coach Bobby Knight, he does not soothe either, like Coach K of the Duke University basketball team. NBA coach Pat Riley tells players: “I need your voluntary cooperation to push you beyond where you can go...”. Toyota would be the drill instructor who may push you to the breaking point, but who would also give his life for you on the battlefield. Tough love, as they say. Perhaps not for everyone, but definitely part of the Toyota Way.

Respect is not necessarily about making individuals feel good in some abstract way. As Jim Womack says in his December 2007 e-letter, ‘Respect for People’, “The manager challenges the employee every step of the way, asking them to think harder, to show more facts, to discuss it further, when what the employees want is just to implement their favorite solutions. Over time, I learned that this problem-solving process is actually the highest form of respect.”

So a certain degree of aggressiveness may be necessary at times, especially in the gritty business of manufacturing, such as automobiles. The process of several thousand people working together to assemble tens of thousands of parts converging one per minute to make up an automobile is hard work, demanding genuine discipline. Even so, there were cases at the old Toyota that many observers might protest. And I imagine traces of that Toyota can still be found lurking suspiciously, especially at the end of a bad day. However, these are only some dimensions of the company that decades ago some leaders recognized as needing change. President Fujio Cho and others sought in Toyota a representation of the best of both worlds. The best of both worlds in several dimensions: old and new; east and west; north and south; tradition and change; demanding but serene. Always improving, changing, building and incorporating the best we can hope for in working together for human purposes. That is the goal: and then there is the plan versus the real thing.

Read also: continue your learning journey

Productivity theater: why being busy is not the same as delivering value

Lean It Up

Productivity theater: why being busy is not the same as delivering value

Read article
Lean leadership: concepts, practices and applications at a Hospital in Foz do Iguaçu

Healthcare

Lean leadership: concepts, practices and applications at a Hospital in Foz do Iguaçu

Read article

From theory to practice: next steps

Team in a consulting meeting

Lean operations consulting

Diagnosis, planning and implementation with experts working directly in your organization's gemba.

Learn more →
Professional organizing sticky notes on a board

Lean training

In-person and online training for leaders who want to implement continuous improvement in their organizations.

See upcoming dates →
Launch of the book Gente Lean — Management is not about tools, it's about people

Turn knowledge into results.

At LeanShop you'll find the leading books, e-books and collections on Lean, Lean Thinking, continuous improvement, leadership and operational excellence to take your management to the next level. Explore content that helps professionals and companies create more value with less waste.

Visit LeanShop now →