We need the right approach for each of the four types of problems we face in management
Today there is already a certain consensus that the essence of every organization is to solve problems – those of its customers, its performance, its employees, etc. And that it is essential for this capability to be developed in all people and built into organizational processes.
Art Smalley, a former Toyota veteran and consultant, puts this issue into a broader perspective. In his latest book, “Four Types of Problems – from reactive troubleshooting to creative innovation”, the author teaches us that there are in fact 4 types of problems and that companies need to develop their own capabilities, and those of their employees, in all of them.
Learning to identify each of these types is the first step, which can help us solve them in a better way. Once we have understood what type of problem we need to solve, we also need to know the appropriate methods for dealing with each of them.
Smalley defines four types of problems: 1- containment, 2 - deviation from standard, 3 - target condition and 4 - innovation. Let's understand each of them:
Type 1 Problem: Containment
When a problem occurs, the first thing we must do is “stop the bleeding”. For example, if a serious quality problem has been detected, we urgently have to stop the machine that generated it, segregate defective parts, replace products that have been shipped to customers, etc. And take steps to quickly restore normal conditions.
This is containment, a reactive action based on quick responses, which provides immediate relief and is necessary so that the damage, such as to the company's image with the customer, to safety, through lost production, etc., does not become even greater. But if the company does only this, and haphazardly, it will not get beyond the well-known “firefighting”, which will be repeated countless times. That would certainly not be lean at all.
Art Smalley reveals in his book that Toyota's high skill at containment is fundamental to developing the basic capabilities needed to tackle the other types of problems. But to do so we have to go beyond the firefighter mindset.
For example, first and foremost, by creating a system for detecting problems while they are still small. This is achieved, for example, by establishing standardized work, visual management, hour-by-hour control of productivity and quality conditions, etc. Containment will then happen at every small deviation, and not only when problems become catastrophes. Operators can count on the help chain of their immediate supervisors, who promptly support them so they can restore the normal condition. And all larger problems, or even small but recurring problems, must have their causes identified and addressed, which brings us to type 2 problems.
Type 2 Problem: Deviation from standard
Let's imagine a process that does not meet requirements. There are productivity, quality or other standards that are not met or that show a lot of variation. These are the famous indicator tracking charts whose actual results are always below target (some use red faces, and how many of those we see in every company…). This is a type 2 problem.
Here it is up to the team involved to carry out the cause analysis – why are we out of standard? – and adopt countermeasures. In many companies, the problem-solving methods taught, often derived from quality tools, aim to prepare teams for activities with this focus. In general, these methods adopt the PDCA (Plan-Do-Check-Act) structure and use the scientific method, enabling people to arrive at effective countermeasures that block the causes and prevent the problem from happening again. In this sense, they make a fundamental contribution to process stability and continuous improvement.
Types 1 and 2 refer to problems that were “caused” by some reason or some variation. Dealing with them leads to reactive responses. There was a standard that was not met, and we act to restore it. Many people understand the word “problem” as referring only to these two types.
In the lean concept, we understand a problem to be any result different from the desired performance at any given moment. For example, we may currently be meeting the plan (with no type 1 or 2 problems), but for competitive reasons, the leadership's vision of the future, etc., a new, more demanding standard is sought. This brings us to type 3 and 4 problems, which are “created” problems. These types of problems require proactive responses, which lead to a higher level of results.
Type 3 Problem: Target condition
This problem refers to the pursuit of performance that goes beyond current standards. This pursuit should not be random; it needs to be directed by the organization's broader objectives, through strategic guidelines set by senior management, deploying the vision of the future to all processes and value streams.
When a company, for example, decides to seek a significant improvement in a value stream by making systemic changes, it is establishing a type 3 problem – target condition. When we carry out structured kaizens aimed at specific higher objectives in certain process steps, we are also dealing with type 3 problems.
When we reach the desired target condition, or future state, with new ways of organizing and carrying out activities, we will need many interventions on type 2 and type 1 problems until this new value stream operates stably and fully achieves its objectives.
Type 4 Problem: Innovation
Art Smalley places innovation as the fourth type of problem among those that company management needs to address. Like type 3, it falls into the category of “created”, proactive problems.
It is important to emphasize that incremental innovation exists and is strongly encouraged when teams deal with type 2 and 3 problems. The difference between type 4 and type 3 is that, due to some business decision, a radical or disruptive change is sought that results in new ways of adding value for customers.
Various methodologies have been used for this purpose, always based on ways of creatively solving some real problem of a group of customers. Allowing for their particularities, it is possible to identify in many of them steps similar to the approaches used in the types of problems described above, such as understanding the situation, clearly defining the problem, analysis, synthesis, implementation, testing, learning and iterative cycles.
Keeping these 4 types of problems in mind helps us understand the various levels of improvement that must take place in organizations and how they need to be combined.
I recently did this exercise when visiting a company that applies some interesting practices, such as visual management and daily meetings to discuss actual vs. planned. When they identified a variation, they immediately carried out containment: for example, by reallocating resources. But that was as far as they went. We can clearly recognize type 1 problems there. Understanding that they should address recurring problems of deviation from standard (type 2) would put them on a path of continuous improvement and stability. Senior management setting challenging goals, seeking improvements across the entire value stream toward a target condition (type 3), would take the company to a new level of performance. Strategic initiatives for radical change in products, processes and services through innovation (type 4) could take the business to a new competitive level.
Smalley is very emphatic in stating that a company's success depends on its mastery of all four types of problems and on the combined use of action on all of them. One supports the other. There is no point in having a completely innovative and even disruptive business model (type 4) and not having excellent processes (type 3) that support the delivery of value to the customer. Or in not reacting well to deviations (types 1 and 2), causing terrible experiences for its consumers due to basic errors that are not corrected quickly and keep recurring.
Try starting to see, in your own work, the different situations that may characterize problems that fit these four types. Analyze the processes and methods your company has for dealing with each of them and how it prepares people to act in each situation. I am sure you will identify some gaps and realize, together with your colleagues, that making progress in the ways the four types of problems are tackled, in an integrated way, can become an important differentiator.
Finally, don't miss the chance to learn from the best — register now for Lean Summit!